In the New York Times article “Relax, You Don’t Need to Eat Clean,” Aaron Carroll writes that food should be “a cause for pleasure, not panic.” He states that people should “cut fear” from their diet. To relax, Carroll suggests people eat bacon and steak.
Carroll erroneously assumes people who eat plant-based food aren’t relaxed and that the aftermath of eating animals is comforting–perhaps for people without a conscience. Eating clean is relaxing, exciting, rewarding, energy-boosting, and responsible. Eating animals should instill fear in everyone far beyond the health risks Carroll dismisses.
While Carroll is correct in his assertion that some people fret too much about gluten, salt, and fat, he misses the mark on eating animals. His comments are irresponsible and myopic.
In his recommendation, he conveniently omits the abuse and suffering farm animals endure, the unsustainable environmental havoc caused by animal agriculture, and the fear industry workers experience on the job.
First, eating animals is cruel. Look at how bacon and steak are made. These are real animals, and their fear should matter to everyone.
Second, greenhouse gases and deforestation from animal agriculture are leading contributors to climate change and an insect Armageddon. People probably haven’t been relaxed when their houses have been underwater and they’ve been clinging to trees awaiting rescue boats nor has it been relaxing for people who sought shelter in their swimming pool as their house burned down. Climate change induced droughts that cause famine and disease? Not so relaxing. The alarming loss of our pollinators, also a result of animal agriculture, threatens life on earth.
Finally, animal agriculture also wastes massive amounts of food, and the companies that turn animals into food are notorious for polluting air and water. Toxic chemicals in drinking water should cause fear, especially with an administration recklessly rolling back regulations designed to protect consumers from such lawbreaking.
Carroll’s suggestion to eat animals is particularly shortsighted because it encourages people to operate at the most elementary level of thinking without making any critical calculations. Carroll’s message is simple: All that matters is what’s in front of you. Don’t think before you eat. He fails to recognize the impact of eating animals goes far beyond cancer, diabetes, heart disease, and other medical conditions it causes.
There’s a large selection of delicious plant-based meats and dairy-free products that replicate the taste, texture, and smell of animal products including Beyond Meat (featured in the photo above), Field Roast, Kite Hill, and Gardein to name a few. They’re healthier, convenient, more sustainable, and humane.
Not even processed meat from plants should be defined as clean or healthy though. It’s healthier but not healthy. Organic fruits, vegetables, nuts, beans, and grains are legitimately clean and healthy–and I don’t get scared when I eat quinoa, avocados, black beans, or lentils. If you want to cut so-called fear from your eating regimen and still enjoy a burger, eat plant-based meat.
Eating should never just be about what’s right for you. It would be best if ate to avoid harming others. Despite what Carroll posits, eating clean and relaxing are not mutually exclusive.
5 thoughts on “Relax and Eat Clean”
so true-thank you!
What an irresponsible article in the NY Times! For all reasons you’ve mentioned above, we should be cutting meat and fish out of our diets. It’s time we thought about the planet, not just our own selfish desires!
Excellent response Andrew. Thank you for spreading the truth.
That’s gotta be a pic of the Beyond Burger, simply the best veggie burger on the market!! Am I right or am I right?? LOL! It has to be cuz I’ve used it to promote it. 😬 This sorry excuse for a person clearly needs to be educated! So sad how some people still think. Wow🤔
Reblogged this on billziegler1947 and commented:
I wish the NYT had asked Andrew Kirschner to write this post on their editorial page. Aaron Carroll’s opinion piece should never have been approved by a media giant that proclaims itself the newspaper of record. I could not have done a better addressing the misinformation myself — actually I would probably have lost myself to rants and ravings, so my grateful appreciation goes to Kirschner’s Korner for countering so much misinformation.